RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: Here' a more detailed thread on the findings of the paper. "Shielding strategies or “focused protection”, as advocated…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: I, like Adam, was always surprised that the GBD folks never explicitly quantified their assumptions and built a model…
You can read a summarised version of our paper "Critical weaknesses in shielding strategies for COVID-19" in the thread below. https://t.co/NlnFlhVPAm^tfw
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: @adamjkucharski We were also surprised that they didn't explicitly model their proposed suggestion, so we did it for t…
Dr Bhattacharya completely fails to engage with the question of what the implications of his GBD would have been. Despite having a modeller as a signatory, GDB folks never modelled their proposals. We did it for them. TL;DR it would have been disastrous.
An important thread on how the alternative GBD proposals of just shield the most vulnerable and let everyone else catch COVID and build herd immunity would have led to far worse outcomes for everyone. We need @evusheld4theuk to protect the immunocompromise
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: @adamjkucharski We were also surprised that they didn't explicitly model their proposed suggestion, so we did it for t…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: I, like Adam, was always surprised that the GBD folks never explicitly quantified their assumptions and built a model…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: @adamjkucharski We were also surprised that they didn't explicitly model their proposed suggestion, so we did it for t…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: @adamjkucharski We were also surprised that they didn't explicitly model their proposed suggestion, so we did it for t…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: I, like Adam, was always surprised that the GBD folks never explicitly quantified their assumptions and built a model…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: Here' a more detailed thread on the findings of the paper. "Shielding strategies or “focused protection”, as advocated…
@AndreasShrugged @adamjkucharski When we sat down and modelled GBD and other shielding strategies they didn't turn out too well. https://t.co/NlnFlhVPAm^tfw
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: I, like Adam, was always surprised that the GBD folks never explicitly quantified their assumptions and built a model…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: @adamjkucharski We were also surprised that they didn't explicitly model their proposed suggestion, so we did it for t…
@adamjkucharski We were also surprised that they didn't explicitly model their proposed suggestion, so we did it for them. The results didn't look pretty. "Focussed protection" would have been a disaster. https://t.co/NlnFlhVPAm^tfw
Here' a more detailed thread on the findings of the paper. "Shielding strategies or “focused protection”, as advocated for in the GBD, would have been impossible to implement in practice and would have likely led to extremely poor outcomes." https://t.co/h
I, like Adam, was always surprised that the GBD folks never explicitly quantified their assumptions and built a model to explore their proposition (esp since one signatory was a modeller). So we did it for them: TL;DR - GBD would have been disastrous. htt
@DennisMaslo @DrJBhattacharya @CDCgov The "GBD policies" are demonstrably untenable, Dr. Jay's sociopathic/eugenicist streak notwithstanding. https://t.co/WQ9xDMLqVv
@DTucker88 @BonnieS21912114 @DrJBhattacharya Honey, whatever Dr. Jay's interest in public (and, by extension, your) health might have been one day, it's long gone in favor of his trying to leverage the stillborn GBD into his retirement portfolio. https://
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: "Focussed protection" would have been an unmitigated disaster. It was always hopium, with no real chance of success.…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: "Focussed protection" would have been an unmitigated disaster. It was always hopium, with no real chance of success.…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: "Focussed protection" would have been an unmitigated disaster. It was always hopium, with no real chance of success.…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: "Focussed protection" would have been an unmitigated disaster. It was always hopium, with no real chance of success.…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: "Focussed protection" would have been an unmitigated disaster. It was always hopium, with no real chance of success.…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: "Focussed protection" would have been an unmitigated disaster. It was always hopium, with no real chance of success.…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: "Focussed protection" would have been an unmitigated disaster. It was always hopium, with no real chance of success.…
"Focussed protection" would have been an unmitigated disaster. It was always hopium, with no real chance of success. Strange that the GBD authors never though to model the impact of their policies. We did: https://t.co/57pFmCeyJf
RT @tomlins_amanda: @ameliaalice1111 @SteveBarclay @NICEComms shielding is not sufficient to protect us - again something we know. It remai…
RT @tomlins_amanda: @ameliaalice1111 @SteveBarclay @NICEComms shielding is not sufficient to protect us - again something we know. It remai…
RT @tomlins_amanda: @ameliaalice1111 @SteveBarclay @NICEComms shielding is not sufficient to protect us - again something we know. It remai…
@ameliaalice1111 @SteveBarclay @NICEComms shielding is not sufficient to protect us - again something we know. It remains unconscionable that the gov opened up and dropped all NPI’s (masks, testing etc) without protecting the #CEV #immunocompromised. 2/2 #
New modeling shows that 'shielding' strategies instead of lockdowns would have led to tens of thousands more deaths https://t.co/KmkCUW7538 https://t.co/TCPA8ZlK4y https://t.co/PQirvqiQQX
RT @themislv_vls: 🧵Plus récemment une étude vient de modéliser la mise en oeuvre de cette stratégie (avant vaccination). Loin de protéger l…
RT @themislv_vls: 🧵Plus récemment une étude vient de modéliser la mise en oeuvre de cette stratégie (avant vaccination). Loin de protéger l…
RT @organichyck: #GreatBarringtonDeclarationBULLSHIT Thank these ABLEISTS EUGENICISTS for the deaths of 1MILLION of our most vulnerable lov…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: Our paper in @PLOSGPH is just out. We modelled shielding strategies like "focussed protection" as espoused by the Gre…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: If you want more detail of the model(s) and our assumptions you can find them in the paper. If you disagree with the…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: Our paper in @PLOSGPH is just out. We modelled shielding strategies like "focussed protection" as espoused by the Gre…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: Our paper in @PLOSGPH is just out. We modelled shielding strategies like "focussed protection" as espoused by the Gre…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: Our paper in @PLOSGPH is just out. We modelled shielding strategies like "focussed protection" as espoused by the Gre…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: Our paper in @PLOSGPH is just out. We modelled shielding strategies like "focussed protection" as espoused by the Gre…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: Our paper in @PLOSGPH is just out. We modelled shielding strategies like "focussed protection" as espoused by the Gre…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: Our paper in @PLOSGPH is just out. We modelled shielding strategies like "focussed protection" as espoused by the Gre…
RT @organichyck: #GreatBarringtonDeclarationBULLSHIT Thank these ABLEISTS EUGENICISTS for the deaths of 1MILLION of our most vulnerable lov…
#GreatBarringtonDeclarationBULLSHIT Thank these ABLEISTS EUGENICISTS for the deaths of 1MILLION of our most vulnerable loved ones. May they experience a speedy and exponential return on their karma: #MartinKulldorff👿#SunetraGupta🤡 #JayBhattarcharya💩
RT @SmartFlightInfo: Shielding vulnerable individuals while allowing infections to spread among the wider population would not have been a…
Sempre per quella questione delle "#chiusure cacca pupù!", della strategia della #Svezia, dell'immunità di gregge e altre puttanate sulle strategie adottate per affrontare la pandemia da #COVID19 https://t.co/MpQt2TxPbB Buona lettura
RT @gianlucac1: Agli asini, ai liberi oltre, ai ristoratori wannabe statistici, nani, ballerine e sfigati vari... dimostrate matematicamen…
Shielding vulnerable individuals while allowing infections to spread among the wider population would not have been a viable public health strategy for #COVID19 and is unlikely to be effective for future pandemics. #pandemic #shielding #control https://t.c
RT @gianlucac1: Agli asini, ai liberi oltre, ai ristoratori wannabe statistici, nani, ballerine e sfigati vari... dimostrate matematicamen…
RT @gianlucac1: Agli asini, ai liberi oltre, ai ristoratori wannabe statistici, nani, ballerine e sfigati vari... dimostrate matematicamen…
RT @gianlucac1: Agli asini, ai liberi oltre, ai ristoratori wannabe statistici, nani, ballerine e sfigati vari... dimostrate matematicamen…
"shielding the vulnerable while allowing infections to spread among the wider population would not have been a viable public health strategy for COVID-19 and is unlikely to be effective for future pandemics" Insomma la verità sta nel mezzo, come sempre? #C
RT @gianlucac1: Agli asini, ai liberi oltre, ai ristoratori wannabe statistici, nani, ballerine e sfigati vari... dimostrate matematicamen…
RT @gianlucac1: Agli asini, ai liberi oltre, ai ristoratori wannabe statistici, nani, ballerine e sfigati vari... dimostrate matematicamen…
RT @gianlucac1: Agli asini, ai liberi oltre, ai ristoratori wannabe statistici, nani, ballerine e sfigati vari... dimostrate matematicamen…
"shielding the vulnerable while allowing infections to spread among the wider population would not have been a viable public health strategy" #PLOSGlobalPublicHealth: https://t.co/ifLhuFvZzJ
Agli asini, ai liberi oltre, ai ristoratori wannabe statistici, nani, ballerine e sfigati vari... dimostrate matematicamente e non con statements pieni di cazzate su twitter che sapete di cosa parlate Come fanno qui https://t.co/tzbQmEp43X forza ci sono
@KashPrime @BallouxFrancois Bad news for those advocating only shielding the vulnerable: Its not a viable alternative! https://t.co/QrytruGEgJ
⬇️⬇️🔥 Maar dit is toch juist wat hier en op vele andere plekken wordt gedaan?
RT @HarrySpoelstra: "Shielding the vulnerable while allowing infections to spread among the wider population would not have been a viable p…
RT @HarrySpoelstra: "Shielding the vulnerable while allowing infections to spread among the wider population would not have been a viable p…
RT @HarrySpoelstra: "Shielding the vulnerable while allowing infections to spread among the wider population would not have been a viable p…
RT @nikomer75: "Proteger a los vulnerables y permitir que las infecciones se propaguen entre la población en general no habría sido una est…
"Proteger a los vulnerables y permitir que las infecciones se propaguen entre la población en general no habría sido una estrategia de salud pública viable para #COVID19 " ➡️ ineficaz para futura pandemia!
"Shielding the vulnerable while allowing infections to spread among the wider population would not have been a viable public health strategy for #COVID19" ➡️ineffective for future pandemic! Critical weaknesses in shielding strategies for COVID-19 https://
RT @chrischirp: Important work examining potential consequences of a "focused protection" strategy. Even under non-waning immunity & perfec…
RT @martinmckee: Remember arguments for “focussed protection” - locking up old and vulnerable while letting everyone else get on with life.…
RT @SeumErgo: Une modélisation tend à confirmer à l'aide de 3 simulations que la stratégie de laisser circuler le virus tout en protégeant…
RT @SeumErgo: Une modélisation tend à confirmer à l'aide de 3 simulations que la stratégie de laisser circuler le virus tout en protégeant…
RT @SeumErgo: Une modélisation tend à confirmer à l'aide de 3 simulations que la stratégie de laisser circuler le virus tout en protégeant…
RT @SeumErgo: Une modélisation tend à confirmer à l'aide de 3 simulations que la stratégie de laisser circuler le virus tout en protégeant…
RT @SeumErgo: Une modélisation tend à confirmer à l'aide de 3 simulations que la stratégie de laisser circuler le virus tout en protégeant…
RT @SeumErgo: Une modélisation tend à confirmer à l'aide de 3 simulations que la stratégie de laisser circuler le virus tout en protégeant…
Une modélisation tend à confirmer à l'aide de 3 simulations que la stratégie de laisser circuler le virus tout en protégeant les plus vulnérables aurait été bien plus meurtrière que les confinements. https://t.co/jU6KEzRCV4 https://t.co/V45RpJI6by
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: Our paper in @PLOSGPH is just out. We modelled shielding strategies like "focussed protection" as espoused by the Gre…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: Our paper in @PLOSGPH is just out. We modelled shielding strategies like "focussed protection" as espoused by the Gre…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: More details on the paper in this thread 👇 TL:DR The Great Barrington Declaration's suggestions, if implemented would…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: More details on the paper in this thread 👇 TL:DR The Great Barrington Declaration's suggestions, if implemented would…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: More details on the paper in this thread 👇 TL:DR The Great Barrington Declaration's suggestions, if implemented would…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: More details on the paper in this thread 👇 TL:DR The Great Barrington Declaration's suggestions, if implemented would…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: More details on the paper in this thread 👇 TL:DR The Great Barrington Declaration's suggestions, if implemented would…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: More details on the paper in this thread 👇 TL:DR The Great Barrington Declaration's suggestions, if implemented would…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: Our paper in @PLOSGPH is just out. We modelled shielding strategies like "focussed protection" as espoused by the Gre…
More details on the paper in this thread 👇 TL:DR The Great Barrington Declaration's suggestions, if implemented would have been disastrous. Huge numbers of people would have died and critical care capacity would have been overwhelmed many times over. http
RT @GANyborg: The study finds that even in the highly unrealistic scenario of perfect shielding, “ICU bed capacity in England would have be…
RT @PLOSGPH: This study retrospectively explores the effectiveness of shielding strategies, showing that even under the unrealistic assumpt…
RT @PLOSGPH: This study retrospectively explores the effectiveness of shielding strategies, showing that even under the unrealistic assumpt…
RT @PLOSGPH: This study retrospectively explores the effectiveness of shielding strategies, showing that even under the unrealistic assumpt…
This study retrospectively explores the effectiveness of shielding strategies, showing that even under the unrealistic assumption of perfect shielding, hospitals would have been rapidly overwhelmed with many avoidable deaths among lower risk individuals. h
Critical weaknesses in shielding strategies for COVID-19 https://t.co/99myjtrk2J
RT @GlobalPHObserv: Critical weaknesses in shielding strategies for COVID-19 https://t.co/EkBnf2HyTQ
RT @GlobalPHObserv: Critical weaknesses in shielding strategies for COVID-19 https://t.co/EkBnf2HyTQ
Good thing we aren’t actually doing something like this…oh wait…
RT @iPolicy: It's good to see someone finally model the Barrington conjecture on COVID mitigation. This model demonstrates that AIER's plan…
RT @Kit_Yates_Maths: Our paper in @PLOSGPH is just out. We modelled shielding strategies like "focussed protection" as espoused by the Gre…