@hotisphere @JournoJane In case you might go beyond the knee jerk response, here’s why I would disagree, the benefits of culling reduce over time, if you don’t agree that’s fine but here’s some science for you https://t.co/jbQGSWKhJs
@bovinetb Yes correct the study referenced is the Jenkins et al 2010 study which looked at TB trends after culling ended https://t.co/BdAieF1fSY
@GarethEnticott @tomrtwit @Gordon_McGlone @nationaltrust That can lead to controversy which is made even worse when cost benefits are discussed prematurely. https://t.co/dlwS41qCUR
@farminginfife @FrankieCclare @ChrisGPackham @DefraGovUK @RosieWoodroffe Benefits sustained to at least 2012. This is 2 yrs after @RosieWoodroffe discussed end of benefits & culling costs. https://t.co/0AkBGVC7F4
@Mr_TBFree In 2010 @RosieWoodroffe, Donnelly & Jenkins said benefits were no longer detectable 4 yrs after last annual cull. https://t.co/0AkBGVC7F4
RT @bovinetb: @RosieWoodroffe Was this to save embarrassment over your earlier, high profile, "benefits not sustained" paper? https://t.co/…
RT @bovinetb: @RosieWoodroffe Was this to save embarrassment over your earlier, high profile, "benefits not sustained" paper? https://t.co/…
@RosieWoodroffe Was this to save embarrassment over your earlier, high profile, "benefits not sustained" paper? https://t.co/0AkBGVTIwC
@ByrneLuc @cows94 https://t.co/ybB7F1eUYd I wonder if you accept any more now you have the source reference, I doubt it
@leanne_manch @PhilLatham @NualaBugeye @terrierview @domdyer70 Do you think your paper helps? @RosieWoodroffe https://t.co/aufmgZSJ09
@terrierview @bovinetb here you go http://t.co/16oKDdMJsu
@PhilLatham http://t.co/16oKDdMJsu concludes that there is no long term benefit of badger culling on the incidence on bovine TB in cattle
@bovinetb ISG members presented a whole paper based on this incorrect data saying culling benefits are not sustained. http://t.co/0AkBGVC7F4
@Upland_Grazing This is the paper where the scientists wrongly stated that the culling benefits were not long lasting http://t.co/0AkBGVC7F4
@terrierview ISG published too early & concluded effects short-lived based on Feb 2010 data. http://t.co/0AkBGVC7F4 http://t.co/dNFH6j9bCa
@terrierview ISG published too early & concluded effects short-lived based on Feb 2010 data. http://t.co/0AkBGVC7F4 … http://t.co/re3gEvfJt8
@PhilLatham = Jenkins 2010 who concludes badger culling unlikely to contribute to the control of cattle TB in Britain http://t.co/9VF8F0DHlR
@terrierview @pengraiggoch @wakefieldgreen the subsequent Jenkins paper concluded no long term benefit from the cull. http://t.co/I9lhh9TyWe
@SarahMDurant @Badgergate @spartacus303 @RobbieAMcDonald Science has moved on since that date in 2009 http://t.co/hu6cVHpaDX
@ecobadger @1GarethWynJones @Mr_TBFree Sure: http://t.co/qVG4SJyU5z The graph attached shows long term effects 10yrs http://t.co/wTdvM4ovEC
Reductions in cattle TB from badger culling not sustained in the long term & did not offset the financial costs. http://t.co/bVTfQGXGwX
@terrierview @PhilLatham link to paper here http://t.co/SO1H5Xlkfo
@NaturalEngland READ THIS AND WAKE UP TO THE FACTS ! http://t.co/8z1hHaiCSc
@DefraGovUK @ChiefVetUK READ THIS AND WAKE UP TO THE FACTS ! http://t.co/8z1hHaiCSc
@BadgerlandCoUk @RosieWoodroffe This is much more up to date (see comments for further updates since 2010): http://t.co/scZaycSIzg
@Badger_Friendly "badger culling is unlikely to contribute effectively to the control of cattle TB in Britain". http://t.co/Twe9bk0FD8
@spartacus303 @AndrewKelly1962 In relation to outcomes of culling, mostly this paper and updates in comments http://t.co/y3yH0Cfkw6
"badger culling is unlikely to contribute effectively to the control of cattle TB in Britain" http://t.co/4cIeG7gSdY
"badger culling is unlikely to contribute effectively to the control of cattle TB in Britain" http://t.co/4cIeG7gSdY
"badger culling is unlikely to contribute effectively to the control of cattle TB in Britain" http://t.co/4cIeG7gSdY
@Badgergate see tables 1 and 2 http://t.co/1sTOBs8VtG
Hi @CarolineIrwin3, monitoring since RBCT showed perturbation effect quickly diminshes and long-term benefits remain. http://t.co/5dcErFu7XP
@terrierview @spartacus303 @phillatham costs of #badgercull peer reviewed - see http://t.co/JWChB12HOo - concl benefits did not offset costs
@AnneatSaveMe @PaulaKeaveney Some clever folk disagree: http://t.co/5dKL7GJRhi And badgers eat hedgehogs, now endangered. Food chains, eh?
Open Access: Reduced cattle TB achieved by repeated #badgercull not sustained in the long term after culling ended http://t.co/e61cpvVx
@KesterGMullan Jenkins' paper in PLoS One is a thorough account of what happens to cattle disease if you cull badgers http://t.co/cKQ3ki5d
@ChrisGPackham enjoyed reading exchange in independent today. An extra ref for you, as if any more evidence was needed! http://t.co/me8micOp
http://t.co/me8micOp doc how much evidence is @DefraGovUK prepared to ignore? Culling costs 2-3.5 times the financial benefit it provides
#PLOSONE: The Duration of the Effects of Repeated Widespread Badger Culling on Cattle Tu... http://t.co/bA3jwOHJ
@DefraGovUK @Network4Animals @jonathanryder - benefits not detectable after 4 years - http://t.co/XJ1TMTHG
@DefraGovUK @Network4Animals @jonathanryder - benefits not detectable after 4 years - http://t.co/XJ1TMTHG
RT @LeagueACS: You cannot take one phrase out of a report and ignore it's conclusions - http://bit.ly/pKIHCi #BadgerCull #meles11
RT @LeagueACS: You cannot take one phrase out of a report and ignore it's conclusions - http://bit.ly/pKIHCi #BadgerCull #meles11
RT @LeagueACS: You cannot take one phrase out of a report and ignore it's conclusions - http://bit.ly/pKIHCi #BadgerCull #meles11
RT @LeagueACS: You cannot take one phrase out of a report and ignore it's conclusions - http://bit.ly/pKIHCi #BadgerCull #meles11
RT @LeagueACS: You cannot take one phrase out of a report and ignore it's conclusions - http://bit.ly/pKIHCi #BadgerCull #meles11
RT @LeagueACS: You cannot take one phrase out of a report and ignore it's conclusions - http://bit.ly/pKIHCi #BadgerCull #meles11
RT @LeagueACS: You cannot take one phrase out of a report and ignore it's conclusions - http://bit.ly/pKIHCi #BadgerCull #meles11
You cannot take one phrase out of a report and ignore it's conclusions - http://bit.ly/pKIHCi #BadgerCull #meles11